← ALL LABSCOE 526 Interactive Privacy Lab Index Lecture 03 • Term 261

Privacy Assessment Lab

COE526 Lecture 03 · from what a system does, to who it hurts, to a decision you can defend

Step 1 · Screen

Does this need a full assessment?

Tick every signal you can see in the case. The law sets the legal threshold; this screen also gives you a reason you can write down and defend.

This list is not complete. One signal can be enough on its own. Whichever way you decide, write down why.
Step 2 · Map

Describe what the system does, before you score it

Keep why separate from how. Follow the data all the way through: collected, guessed at, used, stored, shared, deleted.

Step 3 · Choose and rate risks

Write three risks that name a real person

Each risk must join four things: what the system does, the setting, who is affected, and what goes wrong for them. Cover normal operation as well as things going wrong.

Step 4 · Treat and re-score

Treat the cause, prove it works, then score what is left

Try to remove or replace the feature, collect less by default, or keep data on the device — before you fall back on a notice, a contract or training. The score that matters is the one left over after the control works.

Where your risks sit
Before the control
After the control
Rate a risk to see it appear.
Three questions for every control: how does it change the risk? Who owns it? What evidence would prove it is working?
Step 5 · Decide

Decide, using the risk that is left over

A score cannot accept risk — only a person can. Name who decides, on what conditions, with what evidence, and what would reopen it.

Decision
Step 6 · Defend the decision

Submit, compare, and explain yourself

Under the facts given, one answer fits best. In real work a different answer can also be defensible — if the different evidence and assumptions are written down.

2Purpose, affected people, actors, and data lifecycle are accurate.
3At least three specific risk statements connect processing to human harms.
2Trigger, necessity, proportionality, and alternatives are reasoned.
2Controls change causes, have owners or evidence, and residual risk is re-rated.
1Decision, accountable owner, uncertainty, and review trigger are clear.
Your assessment, in one picture
Before the control
After the control
Rate a risk to see it appear.
Ready
Sources and current-status notes
  1. Saudi Data and Artificial Intelligence Authority — Personal Data Protection Law Implementing Regulation (especially Articles 16, 25, and 32).
  2. Saudi National Data Governance Platform — Privacy Impact Assessment service.
  3. General Data Protection Regulation (Articles 35–36 and relevant recitals).
  4. European Commission — Data Protection Impact Assessment obligations.
  5. European Data Protection Board — high-risk processing guidelines.
  6. European Data Protection Board — 2026 Data Protection Impact Assessment template explainer.
  7. United States National Institute of Standards and Technology Internal Report 8062 — Privacy Engineering and Risk Model.
  8. National Institute of Standards and Technology — Privacy Framework and Privacy Risk Assessment Methodology resources.
  9. National Institute of Standards and Technology — Privacy Framework 1.1 project status.
  10. International Organization for Standardization / International Electrotechnical Commission 29134:2023 — Privacy impact assessment guidance.
  11. International Organization for Standardization / International Electrotechnical Commission 27557:2022 — Organizational privacy risk management.
  12. European Data Protection Board — Guidelines 04/2020 on the use of location data and contact-tracing tools (basis for the contact-tracing scenario).
  13. European Commission eHealth Network — common European Union toolbox for contact-tracing and warning apps.
  14. World Health Organization — ethical considerations for digital proximity tracking.
  15. United States Federal Trade Commission — GoodRx enforcement.
  16. Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada — Tim Hortons findings.
  17. United States Federal Trade Commission — Rite Aid facial-recognition case.

Checked 2 September 2026. The European Data Protection Board 2026 template is identified as a public-consultation version. National Institute of Standards and Technology Privacy Framework 1.0 remains the stable teaching anchor while version 1.1 is still presented by NIST as an update in progress. Scenario summaries distinguish regulator allegations, findings, and orders.